India’s Playing XI: Sudharsan or Reddy to Replace Gill?

By Harshit - Nov 20, 2025 06:01 PM
Last updated on Nov 20, 2025 06:01 PM

India face a crucial challenge ahead of the second Test in Guwahati as captain Shubman Gill has been ruled out due to lack of match fitness. His absence forces the team to rethink its strategies and combinations for a must-win match, especially with the series on the line. The decision has come after medical evaluations suggested that rushing Gill back into action could worsen his condition and impact the upcoming white-ball series as well.

Although Gill travelled with the squad and showed signs of steady recovery, team management and the BCCI medical unit mutually agreed that the risk of aggravation was too high. This unexpected setback has opened the door for new possibilities in India’s Playing XI, with fresh combinations being assessed based on form, balance, and pitch conditions. The focus now shifts to identifying the right replacements who can step up in a high-pressure environment and help India level the series.

With India trailing 0-1 in the series, the upcoming Test carries immense significance. The absence of their captain and key batter has added another layer of complexity, demanding sharper decision-making from the leadership group. As discussions gain pace and selection calls loom large, the Indian team finds itself at a strategic crossroads that could shape the remainder of the series.

Shubman Gill Ruled Out: India Forced to Rethink Their Plans

The news of Shubman Gill missing the second Test has disrupted India’s preparation, especially because the right-hander was central to the team’s batting plans. Even though he had travelled with the squad and hoped to test his fitness with a long net session, the medical team advised against any strain. The priority now is to ensure that he is fully ready for the upcoming ODI series against South Africa.

Gill was initially expected to bat in the nets for at least an hour to assess whether he could handle match intensity. Once this option was ruled out, the management concluded that withdrawal from the Test was the most sensible decision. There is also growing discussion about sending Gill home from Guwahati for more specialised recovery, a call likely to be taken soon by the Indian board.

The Indian thinktank had waited until the last possible moment before taking this decision, hoping Gill would heal in time. But given the high-stakes nature of the match, risking further injury was deemed unnecessary. This leaves India searching for a dependable No. 4 batter who can anchor the innings in difficult situations.

Rishabh Pant to Lead: New Leadership and New Combinations

With Gill unavailable, deputy Rishabh Pant takes over as captain for the crucial second Test. Pant, who has recently returned to international cricket with strong performances, now faces the added responsibility of leading a side in need of quick adjustments. His leadership will play a huge role in determining India’s approach over the next few days.

The bigger challenge lies in restructuring the Playing XI. The management now needs to choose between talented young batters Sai Sudharsan and Nitish Kumar Reddy. Both players are being considered seriously, especially after India opted for an extra spinner in the previous match. Their inclusion would provide fresh energy to the batting lineup but might require leaving out all-rounder Axar Patel.

There is even deliberation over including both Sai Sudharsan and Nitish Reddy to strengthen the middle order. This would, however, force India to compromise on their spin depth. The final decision will likely depend on the pitch conditions at Barsapara Stadium, which continues to show a green surface that will be trimmed before the match begins.

Pitch Conditions and Strategic Decisions Ahead of the Game

The pitch at Guwahati, which will become India’s 28th Test venue, has a noticeable green tinge but is expected to aid turn once the extra grass is shaved off. India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak maintained secrecy regarding the final Playing XI, refusing to confirm whether the team preferred a right-hander to counter specific South African bowlers.

Kotak dismissed the notion that left-handers struggle more against certain bowlers, pointing out that India had two left-arm spinners in the previous Test while South Africa had several right-handers who managed without major issues. The team believes that quality of play outweighs theoretical matchups, especially in a pressure game like this one.

With India trailing the series, the pitch’s behaviour could heavily influence their selection strategy. The need for turn, bounce, and batting depth must all be balanced carefully. A wrong call in the Playing XI could make the challenge even tougher for India as they aim to avoid a second consecutive home series whitewash under coach Gautam Gambhir.

India Aim to Avoid Another Home Whitewash

The stakes are extremely high for India. Losing the first Test has already put them under pressure, and missing their captain only intensifies the challenge. Gautam Gambhir, in his coaching role, now faces a defining moment—whether he can inspire the team to bounce back and level the series.

India must focus on consistency, discipline, and adapting quickly to the changing match scenario. The younger players in consideration for the Playing XI carry both opportunity and responsibility. Sudharsan and Reddy, if selected, will need to rise to the occasion and complement senior batters like Pant and others.

A strong response from the bowlers will also be crucial, especially in utilising the pitch conditions to their advantage. With expectations high and criticism building, India have no option but to deliver a commanding performance.

Final Thoughts: A Crucial Test Awaits India

The second Test in Guwahati is more than just a match—it is a test of resilience, adaptability, and leadership. India must overcome the setback of losing Shubman Gill and find the right balance in their Playing XI to challenge a confident South African side.

The decisions made in the hours leading up to the match will shape the narrative of this series. Whether it’s selecting between Sudharsan and Reddy, benching Axar Patel, or trusting upcoming players in critical roles, every choice matters. For India, this game is an opportunity to reset, regroup, and reclaim momentum.

If they succeed, it could spark a memorable turnaround. If they falter, it may open wider conversations about the team’s direction and long-term planning. As anticipation builds, fans await to see how India respond under pressure and whether they can stage a strong comeback.

Also Read: Arjun Erigaisi Shock Exit Ends India’s FIDE World Cup Run

« Previous India Playing 11 vs SA: Gill Injury, Will Sai Sudharsan Get a Chance?

Next » Stokes Fires Up England to ‘Create History’ in Ashes Quest